| Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 |
|---|---|---|
| North Star Academy | ||
 - Bye | ||
| North Star Academy | ||
December 15, 2023 37-10  | ||
| Bye | ||
| North Star Academy | ||
| 4. Learning Community CS | December 19, 2023 34-32  | |
December 13, 2023 20-15  | ||
| 4. Learning Community CS | ||
| 5. College Achieve Paterson | ||
| 2. New Horizons Community CS | ||
December 12, 2023  42-21 7. Jersey City Global CS | ||
| 2. New Horizons Community CS | ||
December 15, 2023 18-26 | ||
| 7. Jersey City Global CS | ||
| 3. Philip’s Academy | ||
| 3. Philip’s Academy | ||
December 11, 2023 24-11  | ||
| 3. Philip’s Academy | ||
| 6. Bold Academy |
